The Best Blue Crabs On The Grill

Jump to Recipe

Not So Traditional, Yet Mouthwatering!

While traditional methods of cooking blue crabs often involve steaming or boiling, chargrilling them adds a smoky depth of flavor that elevates the overall experience. The combination of the marinade and basting sauce infuses the crabs with a delectable tanginess and richness that sets this dish apart. The debate on if steaming or boiling is the best cooking method just added this version to the discussion!

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Alden Boudy (@flychefaldenb)

Fresh Over Frozen

Utilizing Fresh Blue Crabs from Louisiana:

1. Authentic Cajun and Creole Flavor: Being from Louisiana, utilizing fresh blue crabs is essential to achieve the authentic Cajun and Creole flavors that are synonymous with the region’s culinary heritage. Fresh blue crabs sourced locally capture the essence of Louisiana’s rich seafood tradition, infusing your dish with a genuine taste of the South.
2. Superior Quality and Freshness: Fresh blue crabs from Louisiana offer superior quality and freshness compared to frozen or imported alternatives. By using locally sourced crabs, you ensure that the seafood is at its peak and that you are working with the best ingredients available, resulting in a dish that is truly exceptional in flavor and texture. The sweet and succulent meat of fresh blue crabs, combined with their natural flavors and textures, ensures that your dish is not only delicious but also memorable!

If you do not have access to fresh blue crabs, the recipe works great with shrimp or even frozen snow crabs.

Putting The Crabs On Ice

Placing live crabs on ice is a humane way to sedate them before cooking. The cold temperature of the ice helps numb and immobilize the crabs, minimizing their stress and discomfort during the cooking process.

• Safety Precaution: Live crabs can be quite active and may pose a safety risk if not properly handled. Placing them on ice helps immobilize the crabs, reducing the risk of injury to both the cook and the crab itself.
• Maintaining Freshness: Cooling live crabs on ice helps maintain their freshness and quality before cooking. By quickly lowering their body temperature, you slow down their metabolism and delay the onset of decay, ensuring that the crab meat remains flavorful and safe to consume.
• Easier Handling: Chilling live crabs on ice makes them easier to handle and prepare for cooking. The cold temperature helps relax their muscles, making it simpler to clean, prep, and cook the crabs effectively.

To remove the top shell (carapace) from a blue crab, follow these steps:

1. Grasp the crab firmly with one hand to hold it steady.

2. Using your other hand, lift up the rear flap known as the apron. For males, the apron is thin and elongated, while females have a wider, more rounded apron.

3. With your thumb, insert it under the carapace near the rear end of the crab and gently lift it up and away from the body.

4. Continue to carefully pull the carapace forward and away from the crab until it detaches completely.

5. Discard the carapace or save it for your stuffed crab recipe and proceed with cleaning out the gills and innards from the exposed body of the blue crab before cooking.

I prefer to leave the yellow part of the innards of a crab when cooking for the following reasons:

1. Enhanced Flavor: The yellow substance, known as the crab fat or tomalley, is a flavorful and rich part of the crab that adds depth and complexity to the dish. When cooked, the tomalley infuses the meat with a luxurious, briny flavor that enhances the overall taste of the crab.
2. Moisture and Tenderness: The tomalley contains natural oils that help keep the crab meat moist and tender during the cooking process. By leaving this part intact, you ensure that the crab retains its natural juiciness and succulence, resulting in a more flavorful and enjoyable dining experience.
3. Traditional Preparation: In many culinary traditions, particularly in regions where crabs are a staple ingredient, leaving the tomalley intact is a customary practice. This not only honors the integrity of the crab but also adds authenticity to the preparation method, preserving the unique taste and texture of the dish.
4. Nutritional Benefits: The tomalley is a source of nutrients such as vitamins, minerals, and omega-3 fatty acids. By including this part in your cooking, you not only enhance the flavor but also incorporate additional nutritional value into your meal, making it a wholesome and satisfying choice.
   

Now with that being said, if you choose to remove it in your recipe that is fine but in my opinion its one of my favorite parts!

Key Ingredients

Italian Dressing: Imparts a tangy and herby flavor to the marinade, providing a delicious base for the crabs.  

Garlic Paste: Adds a robust and aromatic kick to the dish, enhancing the overall flavor profile of the blue crabs.  

Lemon Juice: The acidity of lemon juice adds brightness and freshness to the crabs, balancing the richness of the other ingredients. Lemon pairs well with seafood.  

Butter: Contributes to a rich and savory basting sauce, ensuring the crabs are moist and flavorful as they char-grill.  

Southern Made Creole Seasoning: This seasoning blend infuses the crabs with a Southern-inspired mix of herbs and spices, elevating their taste with a touch of heat and depth.  

Parmesan Cheese: Offers a nutty and salty flavor, creating a crispy, savory crust on the blue crabs as they grill, adding an extra layer of texture and taste to the dish.

FAQ

Q: Can I use a gas or charcoal grill for chargrilling blue crabs?

A: Yes, either type of grill can be used; just ensure it reaches and maintains a temperature of 350 degrees Fahrenheit. However, I recommend using a charcoal grill to add that extra depth of smokiness.

Q: How do I know when the blue crabs are fully cooked?

A: The crabs should have a bright red color, with the meat opaque and firm to the touch.